Skip to main content
Case Study

Negligent care post total hip replacement results in four years of pain and disability

Helen Thompson settled a claim on behalf of Mr C, following negligent postoperative care by an Eastbourne based Orthopaedic Surgeon which resulted in him suffering pain and disability for four years following a total hip replacement.

Mr C was a fit and active ex-Navy serviceman. In his late forties he developed left groin and hip pain and was diagnosed with moderately severe degenerative change in the hip. He underwent a left total hip replacement under the care of a Mr Skyrme at the Esperance Hospital Eastbourne under an NHS initiative.

Within weeks of the hip replacement Mr C started to suffer with pain in his left hip, thigh and knee and the left leg was prone to giving way. X-rays showed evidence of early loosening of the hip prosthesis. It was alleged that the surgeon should have appreciated that Mr C's symptoms and the x-rays suggested early loosening of the prosthesis and that arrangements should have been made for regular follow up with repeat x-rays to monitor the position with a view to revision surgery. Instead, investigations were carried out for a suspected muscular tear, following which, when found to be normal, Mr C was discharged despite ongoing pain and disability. His surgeon advised that his symptoms should settle.

Mr C continued to struggle with deteriorating pain and disability in the left hip for around 4 years before seeking a second opinion. X-rays confirmed loosening of the femoral stem of the prosthesis. Mr C underwent a revision total hip replacement, following which he made a full recovery and was free of pain and disability.

NHS Resolution argued that Mr C was out of time to bring his claim and denied the claim in full. Despite this position, Helen was able to negotiate an early settlement in the sum of £20,000.

Contact us

For further information about orthopaedic surgery negligence claims, please call Helen Thompson on 03304606765 or email


All enquiries are completely free of charge and we will investigate all funding options for you including no win no fee. Find out more about no win no fee claims.

Sign up to our email digest

Click to subscribe or manage your email preferences.