Jonathan Zimmern secures liability after doctor stitches mother's ureters together at Brighton Hospital | Fieldfisher
Skip to main content
Case Study

Jonathan Zimmern secures liability after doctor stitches mother's ureters together at Brighton Hospital

We were instructed by our client Sara following the birth of her second child at Brighton Hospital in September 2012.

Sara had agreed an elective caesarean with the hospital, but when her waters broke in the evening of 6th September, delays in monitoring her labour meant she was already fully dilated by the time she was taken to theatre and it became an emergency procedure.

During the emergency caesarean section, Sara's uterus was perforated.  In the process of repairing it, the doctor stitched her ureters together, unnoticed by the medical team. 

Despite complaining of sharp pain in her abdomen, Sara was discharged four days later. She went back to the hospital twice complaining of increasing pain and was eventually readmitted on 14 September. A CT scan revealed the doctor's mistake, which was causing a build-up of urine and the intense pain. Sara then needed another emergency operation to insert ureteric stents and had a catheter and a urine bag fitted.

Not surprisingly, the experience left Sara with depression. She suffered ongoing urinary tract infections and needed high doses of pain relief. She was unable to look after her family or return to work.   The stents and urine bag were eventually removed two months later, but Sara continued to suffer severe abdominal pain for months afterwards.

In March 2013, Sara instructed Jonathan Zimmern. He arranged comment from an Obstetrician on her care and wrote a letter of claim to Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust.   

In response, the Trust admitted liability. They conceded that, had a caesarean section been performed on Sara's admission to the hospital on 7 September 2012 as planned, she would not have suffered a perforation to her uterus and the subsequent injuries. Following this admission, Jonathan was able to secure a settlement of £32,500 for Sara.

On completion of the case, Sara said:

"I would like to take this opportunity to express my gratitude to you Jonathan for all your efforts and how much they are appreciated".

Contact us

For further information about obstetrics negligence claims and birth injuries to the mother, please call Jonathan Zimmern on 03304606779 or email


All enquiries are completely free of charge and we will investigate all funding options for you including no win, no fee.