£5million settlement in cardiac claim following brain damage | Fieldfisher
Skip to main content
Case Study

£5million settlement in cardiac claim following brain damage

Raheem was born in Iraq. When he was six months old he was diagnosed with a cardiac murmur and was referred to the Harefield Hospital for investigation and possible correction of Fallot’s Tatralogy.

Raheem’s parents brought him to the UK as a private patient. He was admitted for cardiac catheterisation, a routine preliminary investigation to establish whether he was a suitable candidate for corrective surgery.

Raheem's pre-medication prior to the catheterisation included the drug omnopon, a morphine based opiod. Raheem was given 12mg of omnopon, almost three times the correct dose.

As a result, he suffered from the characteristic features of an overdose including drowsiness, cyanosis, poor respiration and hypoxia. The procedure had begun at 12pm and by 7.30pm his neurological condition had deteriorated to the extent that there were signs of severe and by now irreversible brain damage.

The following day Raheem’s leg was recorded as “definitely bluer” and  he then underwent a through knee joint right leg amputation.

The operation to correct the Fallot’s Tatralogy had to be postponed and was eventually carried out successfully.

In the months and years that followed, it became clear that Raheem had suffered catastrophic diffuse brain damage and that he was severely handicapped. He made minimal development and progress and although he has matured to the size of and weight of a man, his abilities have remained those of a very young baby. 

Raheem is very severely disabled mentally and physically and is totally dependent on his parents for all care. He has no use of speech and makes only occasional comprehensible noises. He has negligible vision and is registered blind. He is doubly incontinent. His right arm has a stiff spastic posture and he uses his left arm by preference.

Liability was strenuously denied by the hospital, both at the time of the surgery and during the initial correspondence with the hospital.

However, some twenty-four years after Raheem’s birth and some two years after the initial letter of complaint, liability was admitted.

Nevertheless, the hospital’s advisors continued to fight on quantum of damages, arguing in particular that Raheem had a low life expectation.

The matter came before Mr Justice Astill. After two days of argument the defendants finally made an offer in the sum of £5 million, which was approved by the court.

The case was conducted by Paul McNeil.

Contact us

For further information about cardiac surgery negligence claims and clinical negligence claims, please call Paul McNeil on 0330 460 6804 or email paul.mcneil@fieldfisher.com.


All enquiries are completely free of charge and we will investigate all funding options for you including no win, no fee.

Sign up to our email digest

Click to subscribe or manage your email preferences.