Skip to main content
Case Study

£1.7m settlement for young man left brain-injured by failures at UCLH

Luke was thirty-six years old when he suffered permanent brain damage due to his doctors' failure to diagnose an infection in his heart.  His brother brought a claim on his behalf against University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. He was represented by Medical Negligence Partner, Jonathan Zimmern.

As a young child, Luke was diagnosed with a congenital heart condition known as bicuspid aortic valve (BAV). He was fitted with a mechanical aortic valve as a result. This put him at a significantly increased risk of developing a heart infection (endocarditis).

Luke was under the care of the cardio-thoracic clinic at University College Hospital (UCLH). At an appointment in 2013, he reported experiencing temperatures, night sweats, and shortness of breath - some of the classic symptoms of endocarditis. The consultant noted that further investigations were indicated in light of his mechanical valve, but these were not carried out. Two weeks later, Luke's condition had deteriorated so badly that he was admitted to A&E. He was disorientated and struggling to find words. He had been experiencing cramps, shivering, and hot and cold sweats for five weeks, and had woken that day with severe pain in the back of his head.

Luke had suffered a stroke. This was caused by infected heart tissue travelling up the bloodstream to his brain. Despite specialist neurosurgical intervention, he suffered a significant brain injury, resulting in permanent cognitive and motor impairment. The infection would have been detected weeks earlier had the proper tests been performed following his clinic appointment. After a seven-month hospital stay, Luke was discharged with life-changing disabilities. He is still unable to speak and requires significant assistance with everyday tasks.

The Trust admitted that negligent failures had been made in relation to Luke's clinic appointment, but argued that earlier treatment would not have prevented his brain injury. They maintained that, even with prompt antibiotic treatment, the tragic outcome could not have been avoided. Due to limited medical research, this claim was difficult to disprove. Despite this, Jonathan Zimmern succeeded in obtaining a significant settlement for Luke of £1.7m. These funds will allow him to pay for the support he requires to live as independently as possible.

Contact us

For further information about delayed diagnosis claims and medical negligence claims, please call Jonathan Zimmern on 020 7861 4218 or email


All enquiries are completely free of charge and we will investigate all funding options for you including no win, no fee. Find out more about no win no fee claims

Sign up to our email digest

Click to subscribe or manage your email preferences.