During Claudia’s delivery in 1994 her shoulder became stuck behind her mother’s pubic symphysis (shoulder dystocia).
We argued that the obstetric team failed to apply the correct abdominal pressure on Claudia’s mother to try to dislodge the shoulder. Further that the team applied excessive traction to Claudia’s head and brachial plexus to try to deliver her.
Our medical expert said that the excessive nature of the force used to deliver Claudia was evidenced by the extent of the injury to her brachial plexus. All 5 nerve roots were damaged. This meant that Claudia’s right arm had very limited function. Claudia underwent three attempts at remedial surgery but without success.
The hospital denied liability. It argued the injury happened due to the baby’s posture during the pregnancy or due to the normal forces of delivery.
Before court proceedings were issued the defendant offered to settle the claim for just under £129,000. This was eventually increased to £250,000.
Samantha Critchley who acted for Claudia advised that this was too low given Claudia had suffered such a serious and permanent injury. She therefore issued proceedings at the High Court in April 2008. The hospital indicated their intention to defend the claim, but after further negotiation agreed to
£335,000 in damages. This was approved by the court in March 2009. The case was funded by legal aid.
- You can speak to any member of our Medical Negligence team on freephone 0800 358 3848
- e-Mail us at firstname.lastname@example.org or,
- Complete our short enquiry form.
Contact us on freephone 0800 358 3848
Or start your claim online.
"The group is praised for its commitment to 'demystifying the legal process' while this is a firm for which the client has always been a priority"
Fieldfisher has successfully been recognised as an "Occupation and Asbestos Disease Specialists" Fieldfisher are now recognised as assessors
Charities we support
Settlement after misdiagnosed fourth degree perineal tear left untreated at Croydon Health Service NHS Trust
A claim settles for a mother whose fourth degree perineal tear was misdiagnosed and left untreated at the Croydon Health Service NHS Trust
£75,000 for man left with permanent stoma after failed Hartmann's procedure at Royal London Hospital
Jonathan Zimmern successfully reached settlement for a client left with a permanent stoma after his surgeon at the Royal London Hospital severed his only remaining ureter during a Hartmann's procedure
Assault during reconstructive facial surgery at Ipswich Hospital
Jonathan Zimmern has successfully concluded a case after a surgeon at Ipswich Hospital repeatedly punched a patient in the face during an operation
£95,000 following delay in diagnosing and treating lymphoma at University Hospital Wales
Jonathan Zimmern successfully reached settlement for a client who required a temporary stoma and removal of her right kidney following a delay in diagnosing and treating Hodgkin's lymphoma
£475,000 for Personal Trainer Following Failure to Prescribe Anti-Coagulation Medication at Newham University Hospital After Training Injury
Jonathan Zimmern has successfully concluded a case when staff at Newham University Hospital failed to give appropriate anticoagulation medication following leg surgery
Fieldfisher's Jill Greenfield instructed in first civil claim against Weinstein Corporation on behalf of a client who was sexually assaulted
Civil justice may be the only option for Weinstein’s accusers by Jill Greenfield for The Times' The Brief
Ladies Wot Lunch - Fieldfisher helping to raise funds for the Mick Knighton Mesothelioma Research Fund
On World Cerebral Palsy Day, we reiterate our commitment to preventing hypoxic birth injury in the first place and then securing the best for our clients