After an uncomplicated pregnancy our client's mother attended Addenbrooke’s Hospital on 22 May 2005. She was admitted and a CTG was performed to assess fetal well-being.
There were concerns about decelerations and an artificial rupture of the membranes was performed revealing meconium stained liquor. In fact, the CTG showed a pathological trace and this combined with the meconium stained liquor should have raised serious concerns.
An obstetrician was called and fetal blood sampling was undertaken after a significant delay. Moreover, the obstetrician incorrectly categorised the CTG as “suspicious” rather than “pathological”. Another fetal blood sample was ordered and unsurprisingly showed a worrying increase in acidosis. We alleged that the pathological CTG, the meconium staining and the increase in acidosis were all signs that all responsible obstetricians should have taken immediate action to deliver the baby by 15:45 hours at the latest. In fact the mother was told to start pushing and it was not until 15:37 hours that the CTG was finally recognised by the obstetric team, to be pathologically abnormal. At 15:48 hours a decision was made to perform a caesarean section and the baby was delivered at 16:45 hours with the use of forceps.
Our case was that the decision to delivery interval was too long and longer than the hospital’s own Guidelines for Fetal Monitoring in High Risk Pregnancies and Labour. We also argued that it was a mistake to try to deliver by forceps rather than proceeding directly to a caesarean section. There was very strong evidence to suggest that the hypoxic injury to the baby occurred in the last 20–25 minutes of the labour because of her condition at birth and the evidence in the MRI scans.
Unfortunately our client now suffers from choreoathetoid quadriplegic cerebral palsy with some spastic features. Physically she is significantly disabled although cognitively her intelligence has been largely spared.
Our medical negligence solicitor, Paul McNeil, was instructed in late 2007 and a consultant obstetrician, a neonatologist and a neuro-radiologist were engaged to assist our investigation. The defendants denied liability arguing that all the decisions taken by the obstetric team were reasonable except for the management of the forceps delivery. They also rejected that the injuries occurred in the last 20–25 minutes of the labour. On the defendant’s case the hypoxic injury began as late as 16:41 hours. Indeed it was contended in the defence that the delivery should have been only 4 minutes earlier and that if this had occurred the resultant neurological injury in comparison to the actual outcome would have been “very small” indeed.
Eventually the case was settled on a 100% basis (notwithstanding the defendant's legal and medical arguments) in February 2011. Substantial interim payments were made to cover the costs of care, case management and therapies (in particular speech and language and physiotherapy).Fieldfisher investigated the value of the claim by instructing a raft of experts from an educational psychologist through to an architect. We finally produced our schedule of damages which valued the claim at over £12 million. The counter schedule amounted to a mere £5 million. However, the parties were able to discuss at a round table meeting in September 2012 and the matter was settled with the court's approval in October 2012. The settlement will allow our client to reach her fullest potential and enable her to purchase accommodation to house carers and maybe to fulfil her dream to become an Olympic dressage gold medalist!
If you would like to discuss a possible medical negligence claim contact Paul McNeil on 020 7861 4019 or email firstname.lastname@example.org to discuss your options. Alternatively you can complete our short enquiry form and one of our medical negligence solicitors will be in touch with you.
Contact us on freephone 0800 358 3848
Or start your claim online.
"The group is praised for its commitment to 'demystifying the legal process' while this is a firm for which the client has always been a priority"
Fieldfisher has successfully been recognised as an "Occupation and Asbestos Disease Specialists" Fieldfisher are now recognised as assessors
Charities we support
Tragedy of baby deaths at Nottingham City Hospital must generate change
A report into the death of a baby at Nottingham City Hospital details distressing findings.
Mark Bowman welcomes Jeremy Hunt’s assurances NHS will do better on baby deaths
Jeremy Hunt is proposing changes in the way baby deaths and injuries are to be investigated
Settlement after misdiagnosed fourth degree perineal tear left untreated at Croydon Health Service NHS Trust
A claim settles for a mother whose fourth degree perineal tear was misdiagnosed and left untreated at the Croydon Health Service NHS Trust
The importance of recognising hip dysplasia in new-borns
A failure to diagnose DDH during early childhood can result in disabilities in later life.